Tata Steel to file curative petition on mining tax ruling in SC
13 Nov 2024
2 Min Read
CW Team
Tata Steel plans to file a curative petition in the Supreme Court, challenging a July 25 ruling by the court's nine-judge Constitution Bench that affirmed states' authority to impose cess on mining and mineral-use activities. The steel giant, which operates captive mines in Jharkhand and Odisha, aims to seek relief from the implications of this judgment. Despite the ruling, Tata Steel CEO T V Narendran confirmed that no formal demand has been issued to the company.
The origin of the dispute dates back to the Odisha government鈥檚 Orissa Rural Infrastructure and Socio-Economic Development Act (ORISED) of 2004, which introduced a tax on mineral-bearing land. This legislation led to a Rs 1.29 billion demand from Odisha on Tata Steel's mining activities, a charge the company successfully contested in the Odisha High Court. However, Odisha escalated the matter to the Supreme Court, resulting in the recent ruling in favour of state levies on minerals, with collections permitted retroactively from April 1, 2005.
Tata Steel disclosed, during its Q2FY25 results, that although Odisha鈥檚 appeal is pending before a regular Supreme Court bench, the application and enforcement of the ORISED Act remain uncertain. The company is engaging with state officials to explore viable paths forward, as both the state and central governments acknowledge the importance of not undermining industrial stability. Narendran noted the industry鈥檚 changing landscape since ORISED's enactment, highlighting increased state revenue from mining royalties and the establishment of the District Mineral Foundation (DMF), a mining-funded non-profit supporting districts impacted by mining under the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015.
The company鈥檚 discussions with authorities reflect shared concerns about balancing state interests and industry health. Narendran remarked that excessive taxation on minerals, like coal, could escalate costs across sectors, notably in energy. Tata Steel had previously disclosed a contingent liability of Rs 173.47 billion for its Odisha mines as of June 30, 2024. However, the Q2FY25 notes clarified that no current legal obligation related to ORISED exists, and thus no financial provision has been recorded in its results.
(Business Standard)
Tata Steel plans to file a curative petition in the Supreme Court, challenging a July 25 ruling by the court's nine-judge Constitution Bench that affirmed states' authority to impose cess on mining and mineral-use activities. The steel giant, which operates captive mines in Jharkhand and Odisha, aims to seek relief from the implications of this judgment. Despite the ruling, Tata Steel CEO T V Narendran confirmed that no formal demand has been issued to the company.
The origin of the dispute dates back to the Odisha government鈥檚 Orissa Rural Infrastructure and Socio-Economic Development Act (ORISED) of 2004, which introduced a tax on mineral-bearing land. This legislation led to a Rs 1.29 billion demand from Odisha on Tata Steel's mining activities, a charge the company successfully contested in the Odisha High Court. However, Odisha escalated the matter to the Supreme Court, resulting in the recent ruling in favour of state levies on minerals, with collections permitted retroactively from April 1, 2005.
Tata Steel disclosed, during its Q2FY25 results, that although Odisha鈥檚 appeal is pending before a regular Supreme Court bench, the application and enforcement of the ORISED Act remain uncertain. The company is engaging with state officials to explore viable paths forward, as both the state and central governments acknowledge the importance of not undermining industrial stability. Narendran noted the industry鈥檚 changing landscape since ORISED's enactment, highlighting increased state revenue from mining royalties and the establishment of the District Mineral Foundation (DMF), a mining-funded non-profit supporting districts impacted by mining under the MMDR Amendment Act, 2015.
The company鈥檚 discussions with authorities reflect shared concerns about balancing state interests and industry health. Narendran remarked that excessive taxation on minerals, like coal, could escalate costs across sectors, notably in energy. Tata Steel had previously disclosed a contingent liability of Rs 173.47 billion for its Odisha mines as of June 30, 2024. However, the Q2FY25 notes clarified that no current legal obligation related to ORISED exists, and thus no financial provision has been recorded in its results.
(Business Standard)
Next Story
Reliance, Diehl Advance Pact for Precision-Guided Munitions
Diehl Defence CEO Helmut Rauch and Reliance Group鈥檚 Founder Chairman Anil D. Ambani have held discussions to advance their ongoing strategic partnership focused on Guided and Terminally Guided Munitions (TGM), under a cooperation agreement originally signed in 2019.This collaboration underscores Diehl Defence鈥檚 long-term commitment to the Indian market and its support for the Indian Government鈥檚 Make in India initiative. The partnership鈥檚 current emphasis is on the urgent supply of the Vulcano 155mm Precision Guided Munition system to the Indian Armed Forces.Simultaneously, the 鈥淰ulc..
Next Story
Modis Navnirman to Migrate to Main Board, Merge Subsidiary
Modis Navnirman Limited has announced that its Board of Directors has approved a key strategic initiative involving migration from the BSE SME platform to the Main Board of both BSE and NSE, alongside a merger with its wholly owned subsidiary, Shree Modis Navnirman Private Limited.The move to the main boards marks a major milestone in the company鈥檚 growth trajectory, reflecting its consistent financial performance, robust corporate governance, and long-term commitment to value creation. This transition will grant the company access to a broader investor base, improve market participation, en..
Next Story
Global Capital Flows Remain Subdued, EMEA Leads in Q1 2025
The Bharat InvITs Association鈥檚 industry update for Q1 2025 shows subdued global capital flows, with investment volumes remaining at the lower end of the five-year range despite a late 2024 recovery. According to data from Colliers and MSCI Real Capital Analytics, activity in North America declined slightly, while EMEA maintained steady levels and emerged as the top region for investment in standing assets.The EMEA region now hosts seven of the top ten cross-border capital destinations for standing assets, pushing the United States鈥� share of global activity below 15 per cent. Meanwhile, in..