Bengaluru Civic Body Faces Criticism for Tunnel Road Report Errors
08 Jan 2025
2 Min Read
CW Team
A detailed project report (DPR) for an ambitious tunnel road project in Bengaluru, Karnataka, has raised concerns after it was found to contain several inaccuracies, including environmental discrepancies and references to cities in Maharashtra. The DPR, prepared by New Delhi-based Rodic Consultants and submitted to the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) in November 2024, outlined plans for an 18 km tunnel road connecting Hebbal and Silk Board, at a cost of Rs 90.5 million.
The report, completed in just three months, has been criticised for including traffic volume data from two cities in Maharashtra while discussing traffic patterns in Bengaluru. A specific section of the report, which analyses traffic volumes at Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road, mentions traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik, prompting concerns of a "copy-paste" job.
The report stated that nine cordon points had been identified to understand the traffic characteristics in the study area, followed by a detailed account of traffic flow and counts at various junctions. However, the inclusion of traffic data from cities far from Bengaluru has led to questions about the validity of the entire report.
The tunnel project, which is estimated to cost Rs 126.90 billion, aims to alleviate traffic congestion between the two key junctions, Hebbal and Silk Board. The proposed tunnel is designed to reduce travel time from 90 minutes to just 20 minutes, with three intermediate ramps at Mekhri Circle, Racecourse, and Lalbagh, improving connectivity along the North-South Corridor.
Karnataka鈥檚 Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, who has been advocating for the project as part of his 鈥淏rand Bengaluru鈥� initiative, believes the tunnel will significantly reduce traffic congestion, particularly at the busy Hebbal and Silk Board junctions.
In addition to the DPR, the BBMP had also commissioned a feasibility study for the same corridor from Altinok Consulting at a cost of Rs 40.7 million.
The report鈥檚 quick turnaround, completed in just three months, raised concerns among observers, as DPRs typically take nine months to a year to prepare. For comparison, the DPR for Bengaluru Metro鈥檚 37-km Hebbal-Sarjapur corridor, prepared by RINA Consulting at a cost of Rs 10.5 million, took a full year to complete. This stark difference in both cost and timelines has further fuelled scrutiny regarding the planning process of the tunnel project.
A detailed project report (DPR) for an ambitious tunnel road project in Bengaluru, Karnataka, has raised concerns after it was found to contain several inaccuracies, including environmental discrepancies and references to cities in Maharashtra. The DPR, prepared by New Delhi-based Rodic Consultants and submitted to the Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (BBMP) in November 2024, outlined plans for an 18 km tunnel road connecting Hebbal and Silk Board, at a cost of Rs 90.5 million.
The report, completed in just three months, has been criticised for including traffic volume data from two cities in Maharashtra while discussing traffic patterns in Bengaluru. A specific section of the report, which analyses traffic volumes at Malur Road, Guttahalli Main Road, and NR Road, mentions traffic characteristics between Malegaon and Nashik, prompting concerns of a copy-paste job.
The report stated that nine cordon points had been identified to understand the traffic characteristics in the study area, followed by a detailed account of traffic flow and counts at various junctions. However, the inclusion of traffic data from cities far from Bengaluru has led to questions about the validity of the entire report.
The tunnel project, which is estimated to cost Rs 126.90 billion, aims to alleviate traffic congestion between the two key junctions, Hebbal and Silk Board. The proposed tunnel is designed to reduce travel time from 90 minutes to just 20 minutes, with three intermediate ramps at Mekhri Circle, Racecourse, and Lalbagh, improving connectivity along the North-South Corridor.
Karnataka鈥檚 Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar, who has been advocating for the project as part of his 鈥淏rand Bengaluru鈥� initiative, believes the tunnel will significantly reduce traffic congestion, particularly at the busy Hebbal and Silk Board junctions.
In addition to the DPR, the BBMP had also commissioned a feasibility study for the same corridor from Altinok Consulting at a cost of Rs 40.7 million.
The report鈥檚 quick turnaround, completed in just three months, raised concerns among observers, as DPRs typically take nine months to a year to prepare. For comparison, the DPR for Bengaluru Metro鈥檚 37-km Hebbal-Sarjapur corridor, prepared by RINA Consulting at a cost of Rs 10.5 million, took a full year to complete. This stark difference in both cost and timelines has further fuelled scrutiny regarding the planning process of the tunnel project.
Next Story
Desi Machines Brings Clarity to Equipment Decisions
India鈥檚 construction sector is expanding rapidly 鈥� from metros to villages, activity is surging in roads, bridges, homes, and industrial infrastructure. To support this growth, contractors, builders and machine operators need reliable equipment. However, making the right machinery choice is often confusing and overwhelming. Buyers frequently face uncertainty 鈥� not just over which brand to trust, but over which machine type suits their need. Should one opt for an excavator or backhoe loader? Is it more economical to buy one medium excavator or two smaller ones? Should they buy new or..
Next Story
Omaxe Launches Rs 10 billion Township Project in Amritsar
Real estate major Omaxe has launched a new integrated township, New Amritsar, on the GT Road corridor with an investment of over Rs 10 billion. The company has acquired 260 acres for the project, of which 127 acre will be developed in the first phase through its subsidiaries. Strategically located just 12 minutes from the Golden Temple, the township will include residential plots of 300, 500, and 1000 sq yards, along with commercial spaces, a school, a hotel, an exclusive clubhouse, and infrastructure amenities such as 24x7 security, wide internal roads, landscaped greens, and utility ser..
Next Story
Johnson Controls Debuts OpenBlue Workplace in the Middle East
Johnson Controls (NYSE: JCI), a global leader in smart and sustainable building solutions, has announced the Middle East launch of its OpenBlue Workplace platform, with Dubai serving as the strategic hub. The launch comes as the MEA smart building market is projected to grow from USD 8.06 billion in 2023 to USD 47.52 billion by 2030, according to Grand View Research. OpenBlue Workplace is an Integrated Workplace Management System (IWMS) that enables organisations to enhance real estate efficiency through intelligent space use, workplace planning, asset management, and data-driven decision..